The Best Coffee Shops in Sag Harbor

Discover the best coffee shops in Sag Harbor! From artisanal brews to cozy atmospheres, these top Hamptons coffee spots are perfect for starting your day right. Here are the must-visit coffee shops you must try in Sag Harbor.

Carissa’s Bakery

Carissa’s Bakery, while known for its incredible baked goods, also serves up some of the best coffee in the Hamptons. It’s the ideal place to grab a pastry and a perfectly brewed coffee. Their artisanal approach to baking and brewing sets them apart.

Must Order: Americano or a Seasonal Pastry

Sagtown Coffee

A local favorite, Sagtown Coffee is the go-to spot for many Sag Harbor residents. With its warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly staff, it’s the perfect place to start your day or take a break. Their house blends and single-origin options cater to every coffee lover’s palate.

Must Order: Cappuccino or a Freshly Brewed Drip Coffee

JACK’S STIR BREW COFFEE

Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee, a top Hamptons coffee spot, is famous for the Teddy Boy and Happy Jack drinks. It’s practically a rite of passage for any coffee lover visiting the Hamptons. The Teddy Boy (shot of espresso with sugar and cream; shaken over ice) or the Happy Jack (honey cinnamon latte) are the drinks you’ve got to try, especially if you’re new to Jack’s.

Make sure Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee is at the top of your list for a weekend in the Hamptons!

Must Order: Teddy Boy or Happy Jack

Grindstone Coffee & Donuts

Grindstone Coffee & Donuts offers a combination of excellent coffee and freshly made donuts. It’s a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth and a love for high-quality coffee.

Must Order: Nitro Cold Brew and a Glazed Donut

Modern General Dreamy Coffee Co.

Modern General is not just a coffee shop but a lifestyle store offering an array of goods alongside its Dreamy Coffee Co. The cozy interior and the unique blend of items make it a great place to sip and shop. Some say its the best coffee in Sag Harbor, but you’ll have to see for yourself!

Must Order: Latte or Specialty Tea

Sage & Madison

Located in a charming historic building, Sage & Madison offers a unique coffee experience with a touch of old-world charm. The serene garden seating is perfect for enjoying a peaceful cup of coffee. They also host various events, adding to the community feel.

Must Order: Espresso or an Iced Coffee

Il Cappuccino

Il Cappuccino is a beloved spot known for its authentic Italian coffee experience. The rich, robust flavors of their espresso drinks are sure to transport you straight to Italy. Their cozy interior is reminiscent of a classic Italian café.

Must Order: Espresso or Cappuccino

Espresso Da Asporto

Espresso Da Asporto is a quaint coffee shop offering a variety of traditional espresso drinks. Its intimate setting is perfect for a quick coffee break. Their baristas are passionate about their craft, ensuring a top-notch experience.

Must Order: Macchiato or an Espresso

Harbor Market & Kitchen

Harbor Market & Kitchen offers a fantastic selection of coffee along with a full menu of delicious, organic food. It’s a great spot for a leisurely breakfast or lunch. Their farm-to-table approach guarantees fresh and flavorful dishes.

Must Order: Flat White or a Breakfast Sandwich

Provisions Natural Foods Market & Café

Provisions Natural Foods Market & Café combines healthy, organic food options with great coffee. It’s a popular spot for those looking to enjoy a nutritious meal along with their caffeine fix. Their commitment to sustainability and wellness is evident in every cup and plate.

Must Order: Smoothie or a Chai Latte

Goldberg’s Famous Bagels

Goldberg’s Famous Bagels is well-known for its bagels, but their coffee is also top-notch. It’s the perfect place to grab a quick and satisfying breakfast. Their wide selection of bagels and spreads complements their rich, flavorful coffee perfectly.

Must Order: Coffee and a Bagel with Cream Cheese

Each of these coffee shops brings something unique to the table, making Sag Harbor a fantastic destination for coffee lovers. Whether you prefer a classic espresso or a trendy cold brew, these spots ensure you’ll find your perfect cup. Enjoy your coffee journey through the Hamptons and make sure to visit these top-rated coffee shops in Sag Harbor!