The 7 Best Coffee Shops in Montauk (2025 Guide)
Discover the best coffee shops in Montauk! Whether you’re a beach regular or visiting for a weekend escape, this 2025 guide covers the must-visit spots — from iced lattes to jelly croissants and every cozy coastal vibe in between.
Duryea’s Market + Café
Tucked behind Duryea’s Lobster Deck, this under-the-radar market and café is one of Montauk’s best-kept secrets for a quiet morning coffee. Open early and set on the water, it’s the perfect place to sip a cappuccino and grab a croissant before the crowds roll in. You’ll find espresso drinks, breakfast sandwiches, fresh juices, and a small market stocked with curated pantry staples, flowers, and wine.
- Location: 65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk, NY 11954
- Must Order: Iced oat milk latte + almond croissant
- Why Visit: Waterfront coffee with no wait — ideal for early risers
Left Hand Coffee
Left Hand Coffee is a Montauk staple with cool coastal energy. Tucked near the beach, it serves up some of the best specialty coffee in the Hamptons. The Iced Nutella Latte is a cult favorite – rich, chocolatey, and not too sweet.
- Location: 83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY
- Must Order: Iced Nutella Latte
- Why Visit: Local favorite with beach-town vibes and creative drinks
Bambi’s Café
A cute café tucked away in downtown Montauk, Bambi’s has become a go-to for locals and in-the-know visitors. The vibe is warm and cozy, with great coffee, house-baked pastries, and a welcoming setup that makes you want to linger. Try the Moroccan Mint Tea or their Famous Egg Sammy – you won’t regret it.
- Location: 33 Carl Fisher Plaza, Montauk, NY 11954
- Must Order: Moroccan Mint Tea + Bambi’s Famous Egg Sammy
- Why Visit: Hidden gem with aesthetic charm and standout breakfast
Hampton Coffee Company
Need a reliable coffee and breakfast stop before the beach? Hampton Coffee Co delivers every time. It’s more classic than trendy, but their Shaken Cold Brew with Toasted Marshmallow Syrup hits the sweet spot. Bonus: lots of parking and quick service.
- Location: 732 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY
- Must Order: Shaken Cold Brew with Toasted Marshmallow Syrup
- Why Visit: Fast, no-frills coffee stop that is great before the beach
Montauk Bake Shoppe
This spot is a Montauk institution. Known for its iconic Jelly Croissants (pictured below), Montauk Bake Shoppe draws a line out the door in summer – and it’s worth it. It’s got that classic bakery feel and serves up everything from drip coffee to egg sandwiches and pastries that never miss.
- Location: 29 The Plaza, Montauk, NY
- Must Order: Jelly Croissant + Drip Coffee
- Why Visit: Old-school charm and legendary pastries locals swear by
Mostrador at Marram
Located inside the Marram resort, Mostrador blends Latin American flavors with beachy Montauk energy. They offer a curated coffee menu, plus baked goods and fresh juices. It’s quiet, tucked away, and one of the most aesthetic coffee experiences out east.
- Location: 21 Oceanview Terrace, Montauk, NY (Inside Marram)
- Must Order: Cortado or Flat White + Almond Croissant
- Why Visit: Stylish, serene café inside a luxe beachfront hotel
Bluestone Lane
Bluestone Lane brings its signature Aussie café vibes to downtown Montauk. It’s light, airy, and full of fresh brunch options that go perfectly with their smooth espresso drinks. The avocado toast and flat whites are consistent favorites.
- Location: 786 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954
- Must Order: Flat White + Avocado Toast
- Why Visit: Healthy brunch meets great coffee in a breezy downtown space
Left Hand Coffee is widely loved for its creative drinks, beach-town vibe, and signature Iced Nutella Latte. It’s a local favorite and a must-visit.
Head to Hampton Coffee Company or Montauk Bake Shoppe. Both offer breakfast sandwiches, pastries, and fast service to fuel your beach day.
Yes! Duryea’s Markets has the best coastal views while you sip your morning latte.
Mostrador at Marram is the most aesthetic spot – minimalist, beachy, and tucked inside a boutique hotel steps from the sand.
Final Tips for Coffee in Montauk
- Go early: Most spots open by 7–8 AM and fill up fast, especially in peak summer.
- Parking can be tricky, so walk or bike if you’re staying nearby.
- Looking for strong Wi-Fi? Left Hand and Bluestone Lane are your best bets for remote work or a midmorning laptop break.
Whether you’re beach-bound or just exploring town, Montauk’s coffee scene has something for everyone—from laid-back local favorites to stylish hotel cafés. Bookmark this guide and check back throughout summer -I’ll keep updating it with new spots and seasonal specials as they open!
Join The Newsletter
Enter your email to receive weekly recipes, travel tips + more!
