The Best Ice Cream Shops in the Hamptons

Nothing says summer in the Hamptons like a cone of really good ice cream. Whether you’re strolling through Sag Harbor, spending the day in Montauk, or just looking for a sweet treat after the beach, this list has the must-visit ice cream shops to hit this season.

Montauk

John’s Drive-In

A local legend with homemade flavors and retro charm. The line’s always worth it.

• Must Order: Fluffer-Nutter
• 677 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY

Ralph’s Italian Ices & Ice Cream

A Montauk staple for over a decade, Ralph’s offers more than 100 flavors of hard ice cream and Italian ices. Great for scoops, shakes, and classic Italian ice too.

• Must Order: Cannoli Cream Ice
• 8 S Etna Ave, Montauk, NY

Sag Harbor

BuddaBerry

A stylish spot with frozen yogurt, gelato, and every topping imaginable. Great for kids and adults. Plus, they have vegan sorbets and toppings.

• Must Order: Madagascar Vanilla
• ? 49 Front St, Sag Harbor, NY

Big Olaf’s Ice Cream

A Shelter Island ferry ride away but worth the trip—this spot is beloved for its huge scoops and nostalgic boardwalk vibe.

• Must Order: Vanilla Custard
• 8 Wharf St, Sag Harbor, New York

Southampton

Sip ‘n Soda

A retro ice cream parlor serving classic scoops, floats, and lemon custard since 1958. Think old-school soda fountain vibes.

• Must Order: Coconut ice cream or pineapple float
• 40 Montauk Hwy, Southampton, NY

Sant Ambroeus

Not your average cone. This is where you go for chic gelato in a cute dish post-brunch.

• Must Order: Hazelnut, Passion Fruit
• 30 Main St, Southampton, NY

Bridgehampton / Water Mill

The Candy Kitchen

Old-school diner vibes with milkshakes, scoops, and tons of character.

• Must Order: Vanilla Malted Milkshake
• 2391 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY

Westhampton Beach

Shock Ice Cream

Fun, family-friendly soft serve and sundaes with outdoor seating.

• Must Order: Oreo Flurry
• 99 Main St, Westhampton Beach, NY

East Hampton

A La Mode Shoppe

Small-batch ice cream with unique, allergen-friendly flavors. Makes scoops, sundaes, and boozy floats in a laid-back setting—perfect for health-conscious dessert lovers.

• Must Order: Blueberry Cheesecake
• 35 Newtown Ln, East Hampton, NY

Planning a full food tour out east? Don’t miss my guides to The Best Brunch Spots in the Hamptons, Where to Eat in the Hamptons, and The Best Coffee Shops by Town.