The Best Restaurants in the Hamptons

Looking for the best restaurants in the Hamptons? From local favorites to seasonal pop-ups, discover everything you need to know for an unforgettable dining experience out east.

Montauk

Duryea’s Lobster Deck: Begin your weekend adventure in the Hamptons at Duryea’s Lobster Deck. This iconic spot serves up the freshest seafood against a backdrop that transports you far from the tri-state area. Enjoy the best lobster rolls and seafood platters Montauk has to offer.

Scarpetta Beach: Located at Gurney’s Montauk Resort, Scarpetta Beach delivers Italian-inspired cuisine with a modern twist. Enjoy your meal with breathtaking oceanfront views and be sure to order the spaghetti. This is a must-visit for Italian restaurants in the Hamptons.

Navy Beach: For a quintessential beachfront dining experience, head to Navy Beach. Located right on the sands of Fort Pond Bay, this restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere and a menu focused on coastal eats. Perfect for a dinner with friends or a casual date night.

Surf Lodge: Not just a place to stay, Surf Lodge has a restaurant with incredible sunset views. It’s a prime spot for mingling, live music, and soaking in the Montauk scene. It’s known for its vibrant atmosphere and delicious food.

Gosman’s: As a staple seafood destination in Montauk, Gosman’s Dock is renowned for its fresh seafood and refreshing drinks served in a laid-back coastal atmosphere.

Placebo: A vibrant new addition to Montauk, bursting with Latin flavors and transforming into a high-energy dinner party with guest DJs after 9 PM. For a more intimate cocktail experience, Don Jaguar’s is an exclusive speakeasy lounge, accessible only by invitation or by inquiry at [email protected].

Ocean Club Montauk: A new 200-seat restaurant at the Montauk Yacht Club with offerings like fluke tartare and wood-fired beef with smoked beet ketchup. Ideal for seafood and steak lovers looking for a sophisticated dining experience.

Amagansett

Popup Bagels at the Meeting House: If you haven’t tried these small batch bagels in the city already, this is your sign. Located at the newly reopened Meeting House, place an order here and start your summer mornings with some of the best bagels and delicious schmears at the newly reopened Meeting House.

Wölffer Kitchen: This restaurant offers a menu inspired by local ingredients and pairs perfectly with wines from the renowned Wölffer Estate Vineyard.

The Lobster Roll: Known locally as “Lunch,” The Lobster Roll is famous for its classic lobster rolls served in a casual roadside setting that is a must-try!

East Hampton

Nick & Toni’s: Head to Nick & Toni’s in East Hampton for a delicious Italian dinner. This local spot has some wonderful dishes like steak, pizza, pasta, and their pre-fixe dinner for $29.

The 1770 House: Step into history at The 1770 House, an East Hampton icon. This historic inn boasts a restaurant with a menu that celebrates seasonal and local fare.

Bostwick’s: My favorite restaurant out east has to be Bostwick’s. It’s known for its casual, nautical atmosphere, and has some of the best seafood in the Hamptons. Be sure to order the fried fish tacos, buttered lobster roll, shrimp cocktail and the coconut shrimp spring rolls.

Moby’s: Moby’s is a trendy spot serving wood-fired pizzas, fresh seafood, and Mediterranean-inspired dishes in a chic outdoor garden setting.

The Maidstone Hotel: The Maidstone Hotel’s restaurant offers seasonal, locally sourced cuisine in a historic setting, with options for indoor and outdoor dining.

The Palm: The Palm is an outpost of the iconic steakhouse chain, offering USDA Prime steaks, seafood, and Italian specialties in a sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere.

Southampton

Sant Ambroeus: A favorite among locals, Sant Ambroeus is a great place for lunch or dinner and has a expansive rotation of delicious desserts.

Calissa: Calissa specializes in Mediterranean-inspired cuisine, including wood-fired dishes and an extensive wine list, all enjoyed in a picturesque outdoor garden.

Sag Harbor

Le Bilboquet: Le Bilboquet is a chic French bistro known for its elegant ambiance and classic French dishes, perfect for a refined dining experience with a view.

Sag Harbor Tavern: If you are looking for a classic burger or incredible grilled branzino out east, look no further than Sag Harbor Tavern. They are open Friday-Saturday, kid-friendly, and the perfect spot for a casual dinner.

Hampton Bays

Cowfish: Cowfish offers a diverse menu featuring fresh seafood, sushi, and tropical cocktails right on the water. The perfect place to grab food before your drive out to Montauk!

Have you dined at any of these restaurants in the Hamptons? Share your favorite dishes and dining experiences in the comments below! For more tips on planning the perfect getaway, check out my Guide to a Weekend in the Hamptons.