This post is your insider’s guide to the best coffee shops in The Hamptons. Whether you’re a local in search of a new favorite spot or a visitor seeking a caffeine fix, you’re in for a treat. Beyond the pristine beaches and upscale allure, The Hamptons boasts a vibrant coffee scene. From cozy beachside cafes to trendy urban-inspired spots, these coffee shops promise more than just a caffeine boost; they offer an experience.
Left Hand Coffee
Must Order: Iced Nutella Latte
Left Hand Coffee, situated in the heart of Montauk, stands out as a cherished local gem celebrated for its relaxed coastal ambiance and menu brimming with delightful concoctions. Among their stellar offerings, the Nutella latte steals the show – a delectable twist on the classic coffee, it never fails to hit the spot. Personally, it’s my go-to every time I’m in Montauk.
And if you find yourself craving a hearty breakfast, you’re in for a treat. After savoring your coffee at Left Hand, take a leisurely stroll down to Goldbergs just around the corner. There, you can indulge in a breakfast sandwich that will power you up for a day at the beach. With a diverse array of snacks and drinks, Left Hand is the quintessential starting point for your Montauk adventure.
Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee
Must Order: Teddy Boy or Happy Jack
You won’t want to miss out on Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee—it’s practically a rite of passage for any Hamptons coffee lover. This spot is known for consistently serving up delicious coffee concoctions in the area. The Teddy Boy, a game-changing iced coffee creation, is the drink you’ve got to try, especially if you’re new to Jack’s.
Seriously, ask any local—they’ll tell you the Teddy Boy is where it’s at. It’s so darn good, that you’ll wonder how you ever lived without it. Make sure Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee is at the top of your list for a weekend in the Hamptons!
Hampton Coffee Company
Must Order: Iced Hazelnut Coffee
Looking for a classic morning pick-me-up or a quick breakfast bite? Hampton Coffee Co has got you covered. With an extensive menu offering a wide array of coffee options and delectable bites, you’re sure to find just what you’re craving. Whether it’s a perfectly brewed espresso or a satisfying breakfast burrito to fuel your day, Hampton Coffee Co delivers.
Hampton Chutney Company
Must Order: Iced Cardamon Latte
Hampton Chutney Co is a great spot for a delicious and unique coffee experience. Their cardamom latte, made with almond milk, is a must-try. In addition to their delicious coffee, they also offer a variety of dosas, or Indian crepes, for a savory breakfast option. If you’re looking for something a little out of the ordinary, be sure to check out Hampton Chutney Co.
Must Order: Black & Tan
One of my favorite towns out east is Sag Harbor. There is nothing better than spending the morning exploring all the quaint shops with a coffee in hand from Sagtown Coffee. They exclusively serve La Colombe, which is a favorite of mine, and have a wide variety of bites and baked goods.
While you are in Sag Harbor, I definitely recommend pairing your coffee with a donut from Grindstone Donuts. The dream team combo!
Sylvester & Co. Modern General
Must Order: Cold Brew
If you find yourself strolling through Sag Harbor, don’t miss the chance to stop in Sylvester & Co. Modern General for an afternoon coffee. The coffee is strong and the store has some amazing finds!