6 Coffee Shops You Need to Visit in the Hamptons

Discover the best coffee shops in the Hamptons! Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite hangout or just passing through in need of a caffeine fix, these top Hamptons coffee spots have you covered.

Top Hamptons Coffee Spots You Must Visit

Left Hand Coffee in Montauk is one of my absolute favorite spots in the Hamptons. With its relaxed coastal vibes and seriously good coffee, it’s the perfect place to grab coffee before hitting the beach. They’ve got a great selection of drinks and snacks, plus it’s just a short stroll from several local gems. Personally, I never skip a visit whenever I’m in Montauk—it’s an absolute must!

• Location: 83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954
• Must Order: Iced Nutella Latte
• Why Visit?: Enjoy a laid-back coastal coffee shop just steps from the beach

Feeling adventurous? Check out my day trip to Montauk guide to make the most of your visit!

Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee

Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee is a Hamptons staple, and their Teddy Boy and Happy Jack drinks are always worth ordering. The Teddy Boy—a perfectly balanced mix of espresso, sugar, and cream, shaken over ice—is a classic, while the Happy Jack, a honey cinnamon latte, feels like a warm hug in a cup. If it’s your first visit to Jack’s, these two are a great place to start.

• Location: 146 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930

• Must Order: Teddy Boy, Mountie, Happy Jack

• Why Visit?: It’s the quintessential Hamptons coffee spot—a must-visit for any trip out east!

Hampton Coffee Co.

Need a solid morning pick-me-up or a quick breakfast on the go? Hampton Coffee Co is always a great choice. With a huge coffee menu and plenty of baked goods, there’s something for whatever you’re craving.

• Location: 869 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976
• Must Order: Shaken Cold Brew with Toasted Marshmallow syrup
• Why Visit?: Great spot for a quick coffee and breakfast sandwich start to your day

Hampton Chutney Company

Hampton Chutney Co is a great spot for grabbing a quick bite or iced coffee before heading to the beach. Their cardamom latte is a must-try and they also have a variety of dosas for a savory breakfast option. While it’s not technically a coffee shop, the cardamom latte has me coming back every summer.

• Location: 6 Amagansett Square Dr, Amagansett, NY 11930
• Must Order: Iced Cardamom Latte
• Why Visit?: Great spot to grab lunch before heading to the beach!

Sagtown Coffee

One of my favorite towns out east is Sag Harbor. There is nothing better than spending the morning exploring all the local shops with a coffee in hand from Sagtown Coffee. They exclusively serve La Colombe coffee and have a wide variety of bites and baked goods.

• Location: 78 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
• Must Order: Black & Tan
• Why Visit?: Enjoy high-quality coffee while exploring the charming Sag Harbor shops

While you are in Sag Harbor, I definitely recommend pairing your coffee with a donut from Grindstone Donuts. Don’t leave town without picking up a donut—or a dozen!

Check out my Sag Harbor travel guide for more things to do while you are in the area!

Modern General Dreamy Coffee Co.

If you find yourself strolling through Sag Harbor, don’t miss the chance to stop in Sylvester & Co. Modern General for an afternoon coffee. In the back of the store, you’ll find Dreamy Coffee Co. It’s a great spot to pick up some great home finds and even better coffee.

• Location: 103 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
• Must Order: Coconut Cold Brew
• Why Visit?: Unique finds and coffee in a cool, eclectic store